The JSE has censured former Steinhoff CEO Markus Jooste for cooking the books to deliberately mislead the market. Source: Reuters/Siphiwe Sibeko.
Every part of Daily Maverick is free-to-air and no payment is required, although free registration is required for a small subset of functions and pages. Daily Maverick is a unique blend of news, information, analysis and opinion delivered from our newsrooms in Cape Town and Johannesburg, South Africa. [on Daily Maverick](https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2023-01-10-markus-jooste-fined-r15m-banned-from-directorships-at-listed-companies-for-20-years/).
Former Steinhoff CEO is potentially facing a multi-million rand fine after listing violations and phony statements.
While the tribunal has dismissed Jooste application, the payment of the fines are still being reconsidered. [insider trading](https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-12-07/steinhoff-ex-ceo-jooste-has-insider-trading-fine-cut-to-1-2-million) was cut in December by almost 90% to 20 million rand. Despite his fines being drastically cut in December, the JSE persists in its opposition of the reassessment application and anticipates the tribunal’s decision on the ex-CEO’s fines. Jooste has told the JSE Ltd. South Africa’s main stock exchange also barred Jooste from holding an office in a listed company for 20 years, according to a statement Tuesday. He contended the JSE’s findings but his application was dismissed by the tribunal.
The Johannesburg Stock Exchange plans to fine Steinhoff International Holdings NV former CEO Markus Jooste R15m for violating listing rules and submitting ...
Jooste is among four people who will go on trial in Germany next year on charges of accounting fraud. On December 14 he approached the Financial Services Tribunal for an order suspending the JSE’s decisions. While the tribunal has dismissed Jooste’s application, the payment of the fines is still being considered.
Disgraced former Steinhoff CEO Markus Jooste has been banned for 20 years from serving as a director of any company listed on the JSE.
“On 14 December 2022, Mr Jooste applied to the Financial Services Tribunal in terms of section 231 of the FSRA for an order suspending the decisions of the JSE. On the same day, Mr Jooste also applied for the reconsideration of the decisions of the JSE in terms of section 230[1] of the FSRA. The JSE will continue to oppose the reconsideration application.” He also instructed others to record the pro-rata contributions in the Steinhoff at Work accounting records for the financial year ended 30 September 2016.” The Steinhoff Group therefore had to restate its financial statements to rectify the incorrect income previously recorded.” There was no actual transaction nor any legitimate commercial reason that supported the information or calculations contained in the handwritten document.”
The Johannesburg Stock Exchange has banned Markus Jooste from serving as a director on any listed company for the next two decades.
Smart or careless move?](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463912/eskom-to-fall-under-the-department-of-energy-smart-or-careless-move) [Energy Analyst, Chris Yelland states that whether Eskom moves or not, the problems will remain.](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463912/eskom-to-fall-under-the-department-of-energy-smart-or-careless-move) [Read More](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463912/eskom-to-fall-under-the-department-of-energy-smart-or-careless-move) [SA Ndlovu Youth Choir to join Top 60 America Got Talent reality show](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463923/sa-ndlovu-youth-choir-to-join-top-60-america-got-talent-reality-show) [The date for America's Got Talent: All Stars reality show is yet to be announced.](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463923/sa-ndlovu-youth-choir-to-join-top-60-america-got-talent-reality-show) [Read More](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463923/sa-ndlovu-youth-choir-to-join-top-60-america-got-talent-reality-show) [New COVID variant won't result in restrictions, vax campaign to be boosted](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463852/new-covid-variant-won-t-result-in-restrictions-vax-campaign-to-be-boosted) [Health Minister Dr Joe Phaahla says there's no need to impose any travel restrictions on any country due to the new sub-variant of globally dominant Omicron dubbed 'The Kraken'.](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463852/new-covid-variant-won-t-result-in-restrictions-vax-campaign-to-be-boosted) [Read More](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463852/new-covid-variant-won-t-result-in-restrictions-vax-campaign-to-be-boosted) [Over 99% of pupils in Gauteng placed in schools](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463875/over-99-of-pupils-in-gauteng-placed-in-schools) [The Gauteng Education Department says over 290 000 Grade 1 and Grade 8 pupils have been placed.](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463875/over-99-of-pupils-in-gauteng-placed-in-schools) [Read More](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463875/over-99-of-pupils-in-gauteng-placed-in-schools) [Joburg law firm pursues class action lawsuit after Boksburg explosion](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463874/jhb-law-firm-pursuing-a-class-action-lawsuit-after-boksburg-explosion) [A Johannesburg firm is helping families file a class action lawsuit after the explosion of a petrol tanker in Boksburg, which claimed 37 lives.](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463874/jhb-law-firm-pursuing-a-class-action-lawsuit-after-boksburg-explosion) [Read More](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463874/jhb-law-firm-pursuing-a-class-action-lawsuit-after-boksburg-explosion) He added that the fines against Jooste are the maximum permissible under the current rules. According to Sithole the JSE has said there are two clear charges against Jooste, with regards to providing the JSE with financial statements that were incorrect and also how he conducted himself with regards to transactions that should have been disclosed. While there has been some progress from the JSE in this case, Sithole said that the NPA is unfortunately behind the curve. He added that there is an additional issue for the NPA in allocating the resources necessary to investigate this case. The main problem that we now know is that the NPA has quite simply never had the expertise required to unpack the nature of the crimes that we now know were committed at Steinhoff.Khaya Sithole, Independent Political Analyst Sithole said the fines are the maximum amount that can be issued under the current rules. [Picture: EWN](Picture: EWN) [More from Local](https://www.702.co.za/topic/22/local) [SAFTU calls for protection of Fort Hare University executives after attack on VC](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463981/saftu-calls-for-protection-of-fort-hare-university-executives-after-attack-on-vc) [SAFTU called for extra protection for the Fort Hare University Vice-Chancellor after an assassination attempt.](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463981/saftu-calls-for-protection-of-fort-hare-university-executives-after-attack-on-vc) [Read More](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463981/saftu-calls-for-protection-of-fort-hare-university-executives-after-attack-on-vc) [School uniforms: 'No reason why white shirts or grey pants should be branded'](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463927/school-uniforms-no-reason-why-white-shirts-or-grey-pants-should-be-branded) [John Maytham speaks to Siyabulela Makunga, spokesperson for the Competition Commission.](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463927/school-uniforms-no-reason-why-white-shirts-or-grey-pants-should-be-branded) [Read More](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463927/school-uniforms-no-reason-why-white-shirts-or-grey-pants-should-be-branded) [3 South Africans share moving stories of being in exile during apartheid](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463933/3-south-africans-share-moving-stories-of-being-in-exile-during-apartheid) [Clement Manyathela talks to three South Africans who went into exile during apartheid.](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463933/3-south-africans-share-moving-stories-of-being-in-exile-during-apartheid) [Read More](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463933/3-south-africans-share-moving-stories-of-being-in-exile-during-apartheid) [Buying stolen goods makes you biggest criminal - Gift of the Givers's Sooliman](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463931/buying-stolen-goods-makes-you-biggest-criminal-gift-of-the-givers-s-sooliman) [The suspects that came in seven vehicles have been arrested, Imtiaz Sooliman confirms.](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463931/buying-stolen-goods-makes-you-biggest-criminal-gift-of-the-givers-s-sooliman) [Read More](https://www.702.co.za/articles/463931/buying-stolen-goods-makes-you-biggest-criminal-gift-of-the-givers-s-sooliman) [Eskom to fall under the Department of Energy. On top of barring Jooste, the JSE has also levied two R7.5 million fines against him. The Steinhoff scandal, which Jooste was at the centre of, has been regarded as the biggest accounting fraud scandal in the country. Jooste has said he will fight this ban and does not agree with this decision. The former Steinhoff CEO has been barred for the next 20 years as well as being served with two large fines.
GEN – General – Steinhoff International Holdings N.V. Censure imposed by the JSE on Mr Markus Jooste, the former Chief Executive Officer of Steinhoff ...
Accordingly, the JSE found Mr Jooste to be in breach of paragraph 8.62(b) of the Listings Requirements in respect of Steinhoff’s financial information for the 30 June 2015 and prior financial periods when Steinhoff had its primary listing on the JSE, and General Principle (v) in respect of the financial information for the fifteen months ended 30 September 2016 when Steinhoff had a secondary listing on the JSE. In the circumstances, the JSE is entitled to publish this censure, and to disqualify Mr Jooste from holding the office of a director or officer of a listed company for a period of 20 years. On the same day, Mr Jooste also applied for the reconsideration of the decisions of the JSE in terms of section 230(1) of the FSRA. Issuers of securities listed on the JSE are only able to comply with the Listings Requirements if their directors take the appropriate actions to ensure that such issuers comply in all aspects with its provisions and to ensure that the financial information of listed companies are, in all aspects, valid and correct and that it represents a fair and accurate exposition of the company's financial information. On 10 January 2023, the Deputy Chairperson of the Financial Services Tribunal, Retired Judge Harms, dismissed the suspension application, other than in regard to the payment of the fine that the JSE has imposed on Mr Jooste. General Principle (v) as Mr Jooste knew, or ought to have known, that inclusion of the fictitious income in respect of the Steinhoff at Work Transaction would in turn inflate the income recorded in Steinhoff’s consolidated financial statements and contributed to the 2016 financial results being incorrect, false and misleading in material respects; and iii. Mr Jooste was the highest-ranking executive in the Company and bore ultimate responsibility for the decisions and actions of management. The result of this fictitious transaction by the processing of the false invoice was that Steinhoff at Work’s income for the fifteen months ended September 2016 was falsely inflated by R376 649 872, which in turn falsely inflated the income of the Steinhoff Group. Thereafter, other Steinhoff representatives created various documents and gave instructions for monies to be transferred between Steinhoff Group bank accounts to create the impression that the pro rata contributions were actually paid to Steinhoff at Work by the TG Group and to be used as audit evidence for the Steinhoff at Work September 2016 audit (“Steinhoff at Work Transaction”). Pursuant to the JSE’s investigation into the conduct of certain individuals that presided at the Company during the periods in question, the JSE has concluded its investigation against Mr Jooste in his capacity as the Chief Executive Officer of Steinhoff at the time of the transgressions referred to in paragraph 1 above. Mr Jooste gave this handwritten document to Mr Ben La Grange, the Chief Financial Officer of Steinhoff at the time, to generate a false invoice to the TG Group forthe contributionsto be received by Steinhoff at Work from TG Group. Steinhoff joined a structure referred to as the “buying group” through its involvement with the TG Group Holding SA and its subsidiary companies (“TG Group”) whereby volume rebates were purported to be negotiated and collected by TG Group for the Steinhoff Group as well as other third parties.
Markus Jooste is still challenging JSE fines totalling R15 million for his role in the balance sheet scandal.
This is the JSE's public censure against Jooste, who was at the centre of the country's biggest accounting fraud scandal. Chief Executive Officer of the Black ...
“When you look at the 20 years [ban] that they put on him, I think that is not enough, they should have banned him for life, because of what he has done. Chief Executive Officer of the Black Business Council, Kganki Matabane says, “In comparison with [his] salary and the money he made personally, it looks like more of a slap on the wrist. When you look at the severity of what he has done and the punishment that he’s getting it looks like he’s been favoured,” adds Matabane.
Five years after abruptly resigning as Steinhoff's CEO, Markus Jooste may, for the first time, have to defend his record under oath and in court this year.