Thabo Mbeki letter to Paul Mashatile

2023 - 3 - 30

Post cover
Image courtesy of "News24"

Mbeki blasts ANC for wanting to 'protect' Ramaphosa on Phala ... (News24)

Former president Thabo Mbeki has suggested that the ANC used its majority in Parliament to vote against any investigations into the Phala Phala saga because ...

The former statesman said the ANC had to be honest with itself. He added that the ANC wanted to protect Ramaphosa "at all costs". Mbeki warned that the actions of the ANC regarding the Phala Phala issue had the potential of alienating the party from the "masses of our people".

Post cover
Image courtesy of "TimesLIVE"

ANC to meet Mbeki over letter slamming decision to block Phala ... (TimesLIVE)

The ANC will seek a meeting with former president Thabo Mbeki to explain a letter that appears to question the party's decision to “protect at all cost” ...

“The issues that comrade Mbeki is raising are important for the discourse within society and our organisation. “We will process that letter with the former president. The puzzle is why then did we stop an MPC (multi-party committee) being formed if we were convinced it would establish that our president has not done anything impeachable,” the letter reads.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "SABC News"

Mbalula confirms as authentic Mbeki's letter to ANC - SABC News (SABC News)

The African National Congress (ANC) Secretary-General, Fikile Mbalula has confirmed as authentic the leaked letter by former President Thabo Mbeki, ...

It is only then that the ANC will consider a commentary on the contents of that letter and discussions with former President Mbeki,” says Mbalula. We are confident to turn around the municipality and ensure service delivery, and at the same time we’ll act decisively to ensure there is discipline in the organisation,” Mbalula adds. “The ANC finds it regrettable that a letter from former President Thabo Mbeki, directed at national to ANC has landed in the public domain through a leak.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Business Day"

Mbeki slams ANC for thwarting probes of Phala Phala and Eskom (Business Day)

Former president Thabo Mbeki has delivered a scathing critique of ANC deputy president Paul Mashatile, saying it is wrong for the governing party to use its ...

Email [email protected] or call 0860 52 52 00. In a letter dated March 29 and addressed to Mashatile, the party’s public representative in parliament, Mbeki compared the ANC’s actions to it voting against several motions of no confidence against former president Jacob Zuma at the height of state capture... Former president Thabo Mbeki has delivered a scathing critique of ANC deputy president Paul Mashatile and the ANC’s parliamentary caucus, saying it is wrong for the party to use its majority in parliament to veto the establishment of multiparty committees (MPCs) to probe the forex scandal at President Cyril Ramaphosa’s Phala Phala farm and corruption at Eskom.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "SowetanLIVE"

ANC to seek an audience with Mbeki over the Phala Phala letter (SowetanLIVE)

The ANC will seek a meeting with former president Thabo Mbeki to explain a letter that appears to question the party's decision to “protect at all cost” ...

“The national officials will discuss the letter and will seek an audience with the former president. It is only then that the ANC will give a comment on the letter and discuss its contents. This is not the first letter, there are a number of letters that former presidents have written.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Daily Maverick"

Mbeki lashes ANC's block on parliamentary probes into Phala Phala ... (Daily Maverick)

Phala Phala: The former president says the ANC use of its parliamentary majority to railroad investigations by the legislature is unconstitutional.

In July last year, Mbeki was scathing of the ANC for failing on poverty alleviation and reducing inequality, saying that the party risked its own Arab spring if it did not address these burning issues. He used voting figures showing that the ANC’s margin of victory had declined precipitously from 2004 to the last local government election in 2021. The most quoted line is, “The ANC may not stand alone in the dock, but it does stand as accused number one.” He says that in nine months since former spy boss Arthur Fraser laid the Phala Phala charges at the Rosebank police station, “none of the questions has been answered. In October last year, he warned the ANC that it had to prepare for a fallout over the The recent report by SARS Commissioner Edward Kieswetter that no record of the declaration to Customs has been found of the $580,0000 deepens the puzzle about what exactly happened at Phala Phala farm.” “The way we (the ANC) voted on 13 December 2022 to block the process of the formation of an MPC [multi-party committee] communicated the unequivocal statement to the masses of the people that we do not want Parliament to seek and gain a deeper and comprehensive understanding of the Phala Phala matter.”

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Independent Online"

Here is what Thabo Mbeki said about Phala Phala and other matters ... (Independent Online)

Johannesburg - Former ANC and South African President Thabo Mbeki has once again thrown the cat among the pigeons in a letter he wrote to the governing ...

It is equally without doubt that any wrong position we take with regard to the Phala Phala matter will also in equal measure or more, impact negatively on the standing of the ANC with many among the masses of our people!” Mbeki wrote to Mashatile. Without doubt, the wrong positions we took with regard to the Nkandla matter, impacted negatively on the standing of the ANC with many among the masses of our people. [Phala Phala scandal](https://www.iol.co.za/news/politics/mbeki-says-public-protector-report-on-phala-phala-not-final-didnt-clear-ramaphosa-f7cdf0a2-6601-41a5-bab0-8a3655e8d09f) that has consumed the party and President Cyril Ramaphosa for almost a year. “What should have followed this is that the National Assembly would have appointed a Multi-Party Committee (MPC) precisely to investigate the matter of whether the Comrade President did indeed have a case to answer! “As you know, the 3-person Panel appointed by Parliament concerning the Phala Phala matter decided that the Comrade President 'had a case to answer' with regard to a process of impeachment. “In this context, consistent with what Comrade President Ramaphosa said in the Open Letter I have cited, we must be honest with ourselves and understand that many among the masses of our people will entertain the suspicion that the Phala Phala matter includes corruption.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Johannesburg Sunday World"

Mbeki 'ashamed' of Mashatile's majoritarian blind spot (Johannesburg Sunday World)

When Deputy President Paul Mashatile told MPs last Thursday that the ANC would use its numbers in the house to vote as it pleases, his colleagues cheered, ...

“One of these is that parliament has an obligatory constitutional task to exercise oversight over the executive and obviously cannot delegate such oversight to the very same executive and/or its organs. Mbeki said in the eyes of the public, the DA appeared to be “the great champion and defender of our constitution; whereas the ANC is a determined and committed violator of that constitution”. “This I must also say, that it was very embarrassing, to the point of humiliation, that a message could be communicated to the public in such a glaring manner.”

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Politicsweb"

Phala Phala: Thabo Mbeki`s letter to Paul Mashatile - DOCUMENTS ... (Politicsweb)

Dear Comrade Deputy President,. Re: National Assembly Votes et al. I address this specific letter to you recalling the position taken by Comrade President ...

"The African National Congress on the basis of its Programme of Action will strive to attain the ideals enshrined in the Freedom Charter with a fu/1 sense of responsibility to the African people and their aspirations. The Court ruled that this was invalid as it was "inconsistent with (the National Assembly) obligations to scrutinise and oversee executive action and to maintain oversight of the exercise of executive powers by the President. The African National Congress will carry on the programme of African liberation and freedom for all to the best of its ability, praying as it works: "HELP US GOD. As you know, the 2017 54th National Conference said this renewal was "an absolute and urgent priority", for"the survival of our qreat movement". These fights among comrades turn the interest of our people off, and push them away from the movement..." Here the majority Party had voted to absolve the President, which became the resolution of the National Assembly. "The National Assembly, and by extension Parliament, is the embodiment of the centuries-old dreams and /egitimate aspirations of all our people. "Ever attempt to have Parliament conduct its Constitutional obligations have been blocked by your Party, rendering Parliament toothless because of the ANC's majority and commitment to shielding the President. "lt also bears the responsibility to play an oversight rote over the Executive and State organs and ensure that constitutional and statutory obligations are properly executed. We have to be sensitive to the concerns that are being raised by our people about our rote as a movement in corrupt activities... The final constitution, supplemented where necessary by national leqislation, shou/d provide for the principles and appropriate/effective mechanisms of participatory democracy, as we/1 as for organs of civil society' .. lt also includes facilitating the creation of a strong, independent civil society, a high degree of accountability, transparency and the right to participate in decision-making processes which affect communities between elections...

Explore the last week